2008/09/22

Driscoll just won't go away

That man Mark Driscoll seems to be everywhere. He was in London recently, but I didn't go and join the fans. Then I got this link to one of the most bizarre sites I've ever seen. I suppose there's no reason why the Song of Songs shouldn't be a cartoon, but ...

And then today, I got news (thanks Martin) of a talk he gave to the Sydney Anglicans, while he was down under recently. The Sydney Anglicans are not known for their relaxed, easy-going attitude, so I can only guess at the response: I guess the blogosphere would tell me if I searched ... the news reached me from a different (geographical and ideological) corner of Australia, so it is certainly travelling.

I would urge you to take a look, and even to listen, if you have time (it takes about an hour). Why? Well, what he says is by turns prophetic and inspirational, brash to the point of being arrogant, wise but hubristic, factually incorrect but searching, and above all entertaining if you can picture the audience. There's much of what he says that horrifies me (though his references to church leaders as "men" will doubtless go over well in Sydney). In general his reformed theology gives me nightmares, but there's not too much theology here. If you can get past the ranting about entrepreneurs, socialism, and the British, there are some nuggets of wisdom there, and, moreover, some good methodological challenges for us all.

In the background, there is much movement going on over the use of words ("emerging" is nearly gone, I think) -- more on that another time. Whatever words you want to use to describe Driscoll, he is a prophetic voice when it comes to making the news of the kingdom relevant today. And his influence seems to be becoming very great. If you pray about things, please pray for him: it would be too easy for his outspoken ways to come before a big fall. And that would hurt a lot of people as it fell. That would be a bad outcome. Pray that his ministry may continue to grow and thrive, all the while becoming more and more Christ-like.


Edit: I sound like a fan. I'm not (see some earlier blog posts). But we do need to listen to many challenging voices if we are better to grasp the truth.

2008/09/16

Poetry

Wouldn't it be poetic if all those bankers loosing their jobs found themselves unable to keep up their mortgage payments, and had to sell their houses, finding themselves in a situation of negative equity, as the economy crashes around them. Somehow it would just begin to vindicate those folks who, having been sold mortgages they couldn't afford, lost all their quality of life as they defaulted on their loans and became that amorphous mass of "sub-prime" debt.

Shadenfraude is such an ugly emotion, however. But I do hope that the news and business reporters who cover this story - which will, I fear continue to get worse before it gets better - will spare a thought for all the individuals caught up in it.

No one is blameless, I fear. The bankers were either negligent, or knew they were living on a bank of shifting sand. The mortgage brokers are perhaps the true villains of the piece. But the hard-up borrowers should surely have known that something seeming too good to be true probably was. The latter get my sympathy, however: surely our calling is to protect the weak and vulnerable - whether that vulnerability arises from weakness or a simple inability to do arithmetic.

Great strides have been made - though there is much more to be done - in the area of fair trade. If at least we make the processes of global trade transparent, we can decide for ourselves whose blood, sweat, and toil we want to exploit. I wonder if there is room for a similar venture in the area of financial transparency. The whole business of "ethical investments" just means that I don't buy shares in tobacco companies and arms manufacturers, as far as I can see. As financial instruments get more and more complex, I should perhaps care exactly how the banks (and others) that I deal with make their money - and where the scope for collateral damage might be.

Teasing that all apart would be quite a job. It would take an institute full of dedicated ex-bankers, I suspect. As well as informing the end customer, it would have an opportunity to engage in lobbying for improved accountability in the banking sector, too.

There are, of course, some people doing much more creative thinking around this subject. There's micro-finance along the lines of Kiva, for example, or Josh's Indian (former) Taxi Fund [how's that going, I wonder? I Googled around for a more up-to-date blog post, but couldn't find the one I wanted]. And there's probably a lot of other things beside.

I fear there will be a lot more fall-out from the banking sector still to come. And too often, those in high finance will forget the little people. Wouldn't it be great for Christians to be known for charting a course through the mess, and helping people get their lives straightened out (rather than for bickering about creationsim, women bishops, or homosexuality). But I'm dreaming.

2008/09/14

Is Ancient Knowledge worth having?

A colourful postcard just came through my letter-box: "Ancient Knowledge", it says, "The Centre for the Study of Self-Knowledge invites you to a series of open lectures: ... Tibetan Psychology (Buhhhata-Consciousness, Ego, Self-Knowledge) ... Mayan Wisdom (Secrets of a lost civilization, pyramids, cosomology) ... Celtic Mysteries (stone circles, leylines, the Runes).

Who believes in this crap? Of course, I have no problem with people studying this stuff for reasons of history or anthropology, but the clear implication of the leaflet (and much else beside) is that we'd be happier, better people if we would just listen to the message of ancient times, and get more in touch with the lifestyle of our cave- or hut-dwelling ancestors.

Well, I don't buy it. Modern life has its problems, but if you want me to swap 21st century medicince, communications, and manufacturing for that of a few thousand years ago, you'll have a long wait. Why suppose that those people were more in touch with truth and reality, and the things that really matter? What possible reason, other than distant romantic mist, is there to suppose that creators of stone circles were wise folk who can give us insights to help our present situation? Perhaps agrarian iron-age hut-dwellers used to sit around the camp-fire and reflect on how much more in touch with the real world the cave-dwelling hunter-gatherers had been.

Of course, such a rant comes with a barb, doesn't it? I came across someone this week declining to follow the ethical teaching of the church, saying that if some people wanted to follow the mythology of a nomadic bronze-age tribe, that was fine, but he shouldn't be expected to join in.

That stings. But I can see where he's coming from. The truth about God surely transcends our circumstances, and if the bible is one of his principal means of revalation, well it cannot be tossed lightly aside. But I'm increasingly coming to the view that we must work much harder to situate that truth for our present generation.

2008/08/09

Obama the antichrist

A post by Brian Maclaren, points to a Time article describing an advert for American TV, evidently endorsed by the McCain campaign, which insinuates that Barack Obama is the Antichrist. This has me alarmed.

What if .......?

No, but seriously: evidently the allusion is to the Left Behind books. I was given the first one, and read it. Well, I remember starting it - there was something to do with the rapture and half-empty aeroplanes, and a charismatic leader sweeping all before him - but I don't remember any more. Perhaps I got fed up with the poor writing, fanciful story, or doubtful theology. But I get the gist: a bright young leader promises marvellous things and is adored by a watching world, even though he truly represents the most manevolent force in all creation. Or something. Must be Mr O. (Is he adored? I think that most of the world is reserving judgement, really. But I digress).

Now, perhaps Mr. McCain actually believes Mr Obama is the Antichrist. In which case he should come out and say it, and have a public debate at that level.

Assuming he does not, what alarms me is that the man who wants to be the leader of the free world seeks to hold that position by scaring a section of his electorate with a proposition he knows to be false. (Hey, the rapture hasn't happened, so in that whacky eschatology, the rise of the Antichrist is premature...) Let me say that again: he wants to be elected on the basis of a plain, clear, bare-faced lie.

I know politics is a messy business, and politician are prone to exaggerate, spin, and generally encourage double-think. But this is different. Which one of the candidates is evil?

2008/07/29

Things I have learned

I've been in the USA for over two weeks. It's my longest ever visit. Watching Fox news has become something of a morbid fascination. Here are some things I have learned:
  • The real problem with universal healthcare is that the 46m people who don't have medical cover right now will want it. And that means they will want doctors. And there aren't enough to go around. So the whole idea is a non-starter.
  • Obama's international tour was foreshadowing his would-be role as Commander-in-Chief. Not as top diplomat, or representative of all branches of government. No; as guy-with-the-nukes. Gee, that's really encouraging.
  • Americans have to tell their doctors which drugs they want. At least, that's what I surmise from the adverts explaining how wonderful the therapies are. In my country, the doctor tells you what she/he thinks would be good for you.
  • Fox news is fair and balanced. Say it every five minutes, like a mantra, you might start to believe it.
  • $4 for a gallon of (albeit ludicrously low-octane) fuel is a lot of money. [Ha! What a joke. No; I don't believe that one.]
  • If you are poor enough to qualify for Medicare, you can still get pressured into buying a top-up card to cover all the things that Medicare doesn't. It could save you thousands of dollars, apparently.
I'm sure there are more gems, but eventually it all just washes over you.

2008/07/27

Preaching by video

So, most of the sermons at Mars Hill church are presented by (live) video. That's of interest to me: I've often wondered how we would "do" church differently if the apostles, or the reformers (or any other era that's had a big impact on how we conceive of what we do) had had access to modern media.

If the objective of the sermon is to teach the Word (as most churches from the somewhat reformed rightwards tend to say it is), then it seems peculiar that, today, we have pastors, lay preachers, and others spending hours preparing sermons for themselves. Some are much more gifted and insightful than others; and some are simply much better communicators: why not have videos of them preaching, teaching, and admonishing, rather than one of us stumbling through our own particular thoughts? You can make a classical evangelical argument out of that: spiritual gifts are given, surely, to the whole church. Modern media means that there really doesn't have to be a one-to-one mapping between gifted preachers and local fellowships.

I see a number of counter-arguments:
  1. The "sermon" isn't really just about teaching the word (or the Word). It's about the formation of the community. It's about deepening the speaker's own spiritual life. It's about addressing the issues germaine to the moment, in the community.
  2. Educational establishments are widely giving up on traditional lectures, finding them to be one of the least effective ways to teach anyone anything, and (with notable exceptions) have not found video a terribly effective substitute. What lesson for the church?
  3. Why get together to watch a video?: we can do that better in the comfort of our own homes. Indeed, watching Driscoll on the big screen is rather like watching the God channel (though I confess he's better than most of the programmes on the there). You can view the video for yourself on the church web site. That is part of the bigger question about why come together at all. What is church for?
  4. There is a huge danger in being attendant upon every word of a man (hey, it's Driscoll I have in mind; no danger of it being a woman in Mars Hill's case) at a distance. I come from a tradition with a deep fear of a "one-man ministry": often a source of eccentricity, heterodoxy, eventually out-and-out manipulation. That's what would worry me most about the set-up at Mars Hill, actually, but in the more general case, this is the most easily answered: the local leadership could select videos from all sorts of different preachers, and thereby gain really rather a balanced view.
Re-imagining our time together as a church fellowship seems terribly important for the present times. The world has changed so much from the era when everyone knew their neighbours, would walk with them to a large local church building, and sit together to receive the word (and sacrament...). We have much less need of large buildings these days, and much more need of community. Much less time, perhaps in a "service", and much more time serving each other and those around. This is not to say that the disciplines of spiritual formation are not needed today - perhaps they are, more than ever - but the shape and form they take can be so, so different, if we allow them to, and if we take advantage of all that the modern world has to offer.